Italian Cuisine in the Cayman Islands

While exploring the Cayman Islands, expect to be overwhelmed by the great number of restaurants and other dining options. Italian food lovers will want to visit those restaurants where it's always on the menu. There's an over-abundance of dining options with this cuisine on the menu.

With so much to try, from the informal setting of Ristorante Pappagallo to the crave-inducing dinner and lunch at Domino's West Bay, there's something special waiting for each traveler and for that special evening you're planning too.

Take a moment to preview this full list of Italian restaurants throughout the Cayman Islands. Find the one that makes your mouth water and click its name to discover the details about its hours, location, and other offerings.

The Lighthouse Restaurant at Breakers

Grand Cayman | (345) 947-2047

The Lighthouse Restaurant at Breakers

The Lighthouse Restaurant at Breakers is on Shamrock Road . Bodden Town is approximately five miles (approximately eight kilometers) to the west. Though one might say the overall focus is Italian-inspired cuisine, this possible dining pick eagerly offers their pizza and seafood.

The Lighthouse is located in the tranquil area of Breakers, where you find the real Cayman. The restaurant is located by the water and the most recognizable feature is the Lighthouse Tower. Inside the restaurant the atmosphere is Nautical and the waiters uniforms is the same as ship officers. They have three dining locations, one is the air conditioned port room and wine cellar where all of their 150 wine collection are stored. The second is the screened-in, air conditioned patio overlooking the ocean. Finally, the most famous and popular dining area is the dock right on top of the water.

Ristorante Ragazzi

Seven Mile Beach | (345) 945-3484

Ristorante Ragazzi is located in the southern part of Seven Mile Beach, on Grand Cayman; two and a half miles (four and a half kilometers) to the north of Georgetown. Patrons who are in the mood for pizza will especially enjoy eating here during a trip to Seven Mile Beach.

Freshness and simplicity are the traits of the preparations by Head Chef, Federico Destro. With the help of top quality ingredients, each day has special items of two appetizers, four main courses, a pizza and pasta. The authentic wood burning pizza oven produces pizzas one could die for. An ideal place for wine aficionados to dawdle around.

Ristorante Pappagallo

West Bay | (345) 949-1119

Ristorante Pappagallo is located toward the heart of West Bay. Fresh seafood and Italian fare are made for each other at this enjoyable restaurant.

Mouth-watering is one of the descriptions of the culinary delights that await you at Ristorante Pappagallo. Fresh seafood as if plucked right from the sea moments before and a number of imported meat favorites are on the menu for those seeking an award-winning dining experience. The menu changes every day to showcase their talents in the kitchen, but some of their signature dishes include Local Catch Ceviche, Burrata Cheese, Lobster Ravioli, Homemade Gnocchi, Lobster and Shrimp Buba style, local daily catch, Rack of Lamb, Braised Beef Short Ribs , Apple-Philo Tart , Tres Leches Cheesecake, and Peanut-butter Pie.

Gino's Pizzeria

Batabano | (345) 943-3663

Gino's Pizzeria is located near Georgetown; it is 3.5 miles to the south of West Bay. Vacationers that desire pizza will wholly enjoy dining here during a visit to Batabano.

Edoardo's

Seven Mile Beach | (345) 945-4408

Edoardo's is situated in Seven Mile Beach, on Grand Cayman; 3.1 miles to the north of Georgetown. Determined not to be a "stale" choice, not only does this place offer Italian themed dishes and of course pasta, but wouldn't you know they're also fawned-over for another favorite, pizza.

This restaurant offers melds the cuisine of the island perfectly with Italian fare. Sampling the seafood is a must here with the lovely prawns to the calamari. Everything is made with the freshest of ingredients and add an extensive list of wines for a winning dining combination.

Italian Restaurants
Name Location Type Phone Number
Casanova Restaurant by the Sea Downtown Georgetown Italian (345) 949-7633
Domino's George Town 0.6 mi. Southeast of Downtown Georgetown Italian --
Domino's Savannah 2.0 mi. West of Central Bodden Town Italian (345) 947-1188
Domino's West Bay 6.4 mi. North of Central Georgetown Italian (345) 949-6633
Edoardo's 3.1 mi. North of Central Georgetown Caribbean, International, Italian (345) 945-4408
Gino's Pizzeria 3.0 mi. North of Central Georgetown Italian (345) 943-3663
LUCA Seven Mile Beach, Western part of the Cayman Islands Italian (345) 623-4550
La Dolce Vita 0.3 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown Italian (345) 946-7678
Papa John's Queens Court Seven Mile Beach Italian (345) 943-7272
Paradise Restaurant by the Sea 0.3 mi. South West of Downtown Georgetown Asian, Caribbean, Italian (345) 945-1444
Pizza Hut Seven Mile Beach 1.6 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown American, Italian (345) 949-8687
Popo Jeb's Pizza 0.3 mi. West of Central West End Chinese, Italian (345) 917-0940
Red Parrot 1.5 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown Italian (345) 949-0088
Ristorante Pappagallo 6.9 mi. North of Central downtown Georgetown International, Italian (345) 949-1119
Ristorante Ragazzi 2.6 mi. North of Central Georgetown Continental, Italian (345) 945-3484
The Lighthouse Restaurant at Breakers 5.0 mi. East of Central Bodden Town Italian (345) 947-2047
Treats Restaurant 1.7 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown American, Italian (345) 945-4262
Wine Down And Gourmet Market 3.7 mi. North of Central Georgetown Caribbean, International, Italian (345) 949-9463

Similar Food

Agua Restaurant

For something different in the same ballpark, you're likely to enjoy similar offerings at places like the following:

Restaurants with Similar Cuisine
Restaurant Name Phone Cuisine Location Island
Deckers (345) 945-6600 Mediterranean 3.7 mi. North of Central Georgetown Grand Cayman
Blue Cilantro (345) 945-4372 Mediterranean 2.6 mi. North of Central Georgetown Grand Cayman
Fidel Murphy's Public House (345) 949-5189 Irish 1.1 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown Grand Cayman
The Bistro (345) 623-6666 French 3.1 mi. North of Central Georgetown Grand Cayman
Over The Edge (345) 947-9568 French 0.6 mi. West of Central Old Man Bay Grand Cayman
Periwinkle (345) 943-9000 Mediterranean 3.3 mi. North of Central Georgetown Grand Cayman
Captain's Table Restaurant (345) 948-1418 European 0.5 mi. Southeast of Central West End Cayman Brac
Al La Kebab (345) 943-4343 Mediterranean 1.6 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown Grand Cayman
A La Kebab 943-4343 Mediterranean 1.6 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown Grand Cayman

Or you could opt to sample the signature items from some of these restaurants:

Restaurants with Similar Specialties
Restaurant Name Phone Specialty Location
Eagle Ray's Dive Bar & Grill (345) 640-8888 Pizza 1.1 mi. Northeast of Central East End
Pelican's Reef Restaurant (345) 947-3100 Pasta 3.6 mi. North-Northeast of Central East End
Agua Restaurant (345) 949-2482 Pasta 2.0 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown
Cimboco Caribbean Cafe (345) 947-2782 Pizza 1.6 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown
Margaritaville Cayman Islands (345) 949-6274 Pizza Downtown Georgetown
Kaibo Beach Bar & Grill (345) 947-9975 Pizza 0.4 mi. South-Southwest of Central Cayman Kai
XQ's Bar & Grill (345) 947-9770 Pasta 1.2 mi. North of Downtown Georgetown

Oftentimes, the best kitchens, cafes, and dining rooms in the Cayman Islands are those you find suddenly while trekking the town of your choice. However, jotting down at least a couple dining options on your itinerary, means you'll have multiple alternatives, even in a pinch. To discover much more about the kinds of food awaiting you, check out this page.

 

Help us improve! We welcome your corrections and suggestions.