Hotel on the Cay

Hotel on the Cay

Ultimate seclusion and tranquility characterize the Hotel on the Cay, located on a cay off of St. Croix's shores for a unique vacation experience. Peace and quiet are easily attainable here, as well as perfect Caribbean sunsets.

Hotel on the Cay can also be a nice spot for travelers looking for some after hours fun. In addition to other possibilities, you'll be able to hang out at their very own bar, which is located conveniently on-site.

Located on the island of Protestant Cay, 0.2 miles northeast of downtown Christiansted, Hotel on the Cay is a great choice for visitors wanting to stay on this beautiful island.


Hotel on the Cay has both rooms and suites, and guests will find both to be luxurious and spacious. Offerings come in Standard Rooms which have two queen-sized beds, and Suites, which also include two queen-sized beds. All rooms feature air-conditioning, view of the Caribbean Ocean, kitchenettes with microwave, refrigerator, toaster, and coffee pot and a balcony and TV. Suites add the amenities of additional space, a second bathroom, and a sofa bed. Suites can sleep up to 6 people.

Hotel on the Cay is a moderate-sized accommodation option, utilizing a sum of 53 rooms. Since it offers a nice balance between small-hotel service and large-resort convenience, many vacationers find that this property is well suited to their personalities.

This hotel has earned a rating of two and a half stars from Caribya! with respect to furnishings, style, public spaces and overall ambience. Learn more about our Caribya! star ratings, and why they tend to be lower than the ratings awarded by Trip Advisor and other sites, by clicking here.

Look below for a listing of in-room amenities offered by Hotel on the Cay.

  • Coffee Maker
  • Toilet
  • Television
  • Ceiling Fan
  • Kitchenette
  • Mini-Fridge
  • Telephone
  • Microwave
  • Air Conditioned
  • Private Bath
  • Ironing Board
  • Water closet
  • Non-Smoking Rooms
  • Iron
  • Hairdryer
  • Internet Access Port
  • Flat Screen TV

If you want a room with a certain amenity, mention this when you contact the front desk or reservation service.

Activities and Amenities

In addition to these in-room amenities, this hotel also offers a few other amenities.

  • Live Entertainment
  • Kayaking
  • Sailing
  • Multilingual
  • Courtyard
  • Fishing
  • Highspeed Internet
  • Wi Fi Internet Access
  • Snorkeling

However, it's a good idea to double check with the property if you want to know exactly what to expect upon arrival. To view an in-depth description about the specific recreation and activities that Hotel on the Cay has to offer, click here.


In addition to the dining options on-location, vacationers looking for further culinary diversity should also investigate some of the area's other nearby restaurant selections. Hungry guests will encounter some nice places to eat within traveling distance. It's a smart idea to know the area's restaurant options, even though Hotel on the Cay offers some tempting choices of their own. For more information about your dining options near this property, click here.

Guest Services

Taking advantage of guest services -- including the ones below -- may help you stay relaxed during your vacation.

  • Guest Laundromat
  • Dry Cleaning/Laundry

There's also some business amenities, helping to keep the visit productive, whether it's for business or pleasure.

  • Conference Facilities


Guests will encounter many interesting sites and attractions located near Hotel on the Cay. Some of these attractions include Peter Carl Limpricht Park, The Lutheran Church, and Government House. Considering this hotel is located right on Sugar Beach, it's an ideal setting for sun-worshippers who can't wait to hit the sand. Also nearby is Grotto Beach, just a few miles from the property.

One of the closest areas to the hotel is Christiansted. To maximize what you see and learn during your trip, have yourself a side trip to a neighboring city to explore the sights and sounds they have to offer.

If you'd like to learn more about what else is in the vicinity of the property, click here.

Contact Info

Location: Protestant Cay, Protestant Cay 00822

General: (855) 654-0301



Help us improve! We welcome your corrections and suggestions.