Italian Cuisine on New Providence Island

Throughout the Bahamas, you'll be impressed by the savory selection of places to have a hot meal. If you're admittedly obsessed with Italian food, you can't afford to miss the places that always feature it on the menu. Fortunately, there's a good bunch of restaurants that offer this favorite.

Restaurants Map

From the pleasant, fine dining setting of Casa D'Angelo to the beautiful smells of dinner and lunch at Cafe Matisse, there is a choice for every type of traveler and every mood.

Below, get more details about this full list of restaurants serving Italian cuisine to be found. Click each option to see the full article about its hours, locale, and even nearby attractions.

Carmine's

Paradise Island | (242) 363-3000

Carmine's, a part of Marina Village, is located 1.5 miles east of downtown Nassau. Guests that desire pasta will wholly love dining here during a trip to Paradise Island.

Carmine's serves authentic Italian fare, with such offerings as veal saltimbocca on the menu. Pair your meal with a selection from the wine menu.

Mahogany House

Lyford Cay | (242) 362-6669

Mahogany House

Set 1.9 miles south-southwest of Gambier, Mahogany House is a part of The Island House, and is a viable option for you to consider if you're going to explore this neighborhood. It is 7.1 miles west-southwest of Cable Beach. Though they're broadly known for Italian food, this visitor favorite will recommend their best: pasta and pizza.

The restaurant is decorated simply, but in no way modestly. The fine architectural style and glassware give it a very defined look that makes you think you should be in formal attire, though that is not unnecessary; you can where sandals and shorts if you so choose.

Casa D'Angelo

Paradise Island | (242) 363-3000

Casa D'Angelo, part of Atlantis Coral Towers, is situated 1.7 miles east-northeast of downtown Nassau. Not only do they have festive fare including Italian goodies, which yes, includes pasta, but wouldn't you know they're also masters of seafood.

Casa D'Angelo mixes the classic stylings of Southern Italy with traditional Bahamian seafood to create a menu that will have everyone drooling. Chef Angelo's specialties are veal chop Milanese and herb-crusted rack of lamb.

Luciano's Of Chicago

Nassau | (242) 323-7770

Located along the northern outskirts of Nassau, Luciano's Of Chicago is on East Bay Street. Not only do they have festive fare including Italian food and desserts, but it's also quite the favorite for seafood.

Hard wood floors, rafters, and finishing stand in contrast to the buttery color of the walls and the elegant place settings at each table. Still, the cozy, home-like atmosphere easily makes every guest feel welcome.

Amici A Trattoria

Cable Beach | (242) 327-6000

Positioned near the heart of Cable Beach, Amici A Trattoria is located at Meliá Nassau Beach. Hoping to have tempting Italian eats in a breezy and inviting location? Then definitely don't miss the naturally relaxing bites and backdrop here.

Italian Restaurants
Name Location Type Phone Number
Amici A Trattoria 0.7 mi. East-Southeast of Central Cable Beach Italian (242) 327-6000
Cafe Matisse Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 356-7012
Capriccio Ristorante 0.1 mi. South-Southwest of Central Cable Beach Italian (242) 327-8547
Carmine's 1.5 mi. East of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 363-3000
Casa D'Angelo 1.7 mi. East-Northeast of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 363-3000
Casetta 1.0 mi. Southeast of Central Cable Beach Italian (242) 677-9000
Domino's Cable Beach 0.1 mi. South-Southeast of Central Cable Beach Italian (242) 677-7200
Domino's Nassau 2.0 mi. South-Southeast of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 394-8080
Luciano's Of Chicago 0.9 mi. East of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 323-7770
Mahogany House 1.9 mi. South-Southwest of Central Gambier International, Italian (242) 362-6669
Marco's Pizza Nassau Italian 361-6900
Marina Pizzeria 1.5 mi. East-Northeast of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 363-3000
Mia's Gourmet Pizzeria 1.8 mi. West of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 356-5633
Sbarro Cable Beach 0.2 mi. South West of Central Cable Beach Italian (242) 327-7711
Sbarro Nassau 2.0 mi. South-Southeast of Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 356-0800
Sharkees Island Pizza Downtown Nassau Italian (242) 367-3535

Similar Food

If you seek even more options in this same genre, perhaps you'll want the familiar flavors at restaurants like the following:

Restaurants with Similar Cuisine
Restaurant Name Phone Cuisine Location
Olive's Mediterranean Cafe (242) 356-3986 Greek Downtown Nassau
Via Caffe (242) 322-7209 European Downtown Nassau
Olives Meze Grill (242) 327-6393 Greek 0.1 mi. South-Southwest of Central Cable Beach
Bennigans Nassau (242) 394-4880 Irish 2.0 mi. South-Southeast of Downtown Nassau
Bennigan's Nassau 394-4880 Irish 2.0 mi. South-Southeast of Downtown Nassau
Montagu Gardens (242) 394-6347 French 2.0 mi. East of Downtown Nassau
Brussels Bistro (242) 326-4523 French Downtown Nassau
Cafe Martinique (242) 363-3000 French 1.4 mi. East of Downtown Nassau
Cleo (242) 677-9000 Mediterranean 0.8 mi. Southeast of Central Cable Beach
Cricket Club Restaurant & Pub 326-4720 British Nassau

Or for yet another culinary cousin, sample a local specialty like the pizza featured at Caribe Cafe.

Visitors often find that the best places to grab a bite in the Bahamas are those that you didn't expect to find yourself craving while walking the streets near your hotel. Of course, you can't go wrong when you have a handful of favorites in mind. To read even more concerning the dining options awaiting you, check out this page.

 

Help us improve! We welcome your corrections and suggestions.

About Food