Italian Cuisine on St. Thomas

During your travels through the Virgin Islands, you'll be able to sample a tempting spread of quick-service, sit-down, and fine dining establishments. Guests who already have plans to eat Italian food can't afford to miss the restaurants known for this style of cooking. Across the Virgin Islands, visitors will find a good bunch of restaurants that offer this favorite.

From the pleasant, informal locale of Pesce to the fantastic dinner and lunch at Domino's Nisky Center, you're sure to locate a menu item with all the right flavors.

Restaurants Map

The following list allows you to read more about the places where guests can grab Italian food. On each restaurant's name, click to get further details about its style, hours, or even what the view will be like.

Café Amici

Downtown Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas | (340) 779-9000

Café Amici, which is on the premises of A.H. Riise, is found within downtown Charlotte Amalie, near the heart of Charlotte Amalie. This local establishment isn't merely Italian delights and particularly pasta, but we shouldn't forget they're also masters of pizza.

The gourmet pizzas at Café Amici are made with whole wheat crust and fired in a stone oven. Sandwiches, salads, soups, and pastas are also available.

Virgilio's Restaurant

Downtown Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas | (340) 776-4920

Virgilio's Restaurant is situated in downtown Charlotte Amalie, just outside the heart of Charlotte Amalie. Perhaps you could guess that this place is best known for Italian cuisine and pasta, but it's also fawned-over for another favorite, pizza.

This dark restaurant is complimented with the light Italian music that floats in the dining room, and the crowded walls that are packed with pictures and wall ornaments.


Red Hook, St. Thomas | (340) 714-7874


Pesce, which is part of American Yacht Harbor, is found near the middle of Red Hook. It's worth noting that within the genre of Italian-inspired cuisine, this local spot is known for its pasta and pizza.

The dining room at Pesce is reminiscent of an old world Italian bistro with comfortable high-back leather seating and purposely distressed walls.

Pie Whole

Frenchtown, St. Thomas | (340) 642-5074

Pie Whole is a popular choice that's worth considering if you're thinking about exploring this neighborhood. It is west of Charlotte Amalie. Here's one sure-fire reason to visit Frenchtown if you're a fan of Italian cuisine, but particularly pizza.

The dining room at Pie Whole is centered around a brick oven, which is always busy firing pizzas. Otherwise, the decor is reminiscent of a New York City diner, with Italian posters on the wall.

Domino's Nisky Center

The vicinity of Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas | (340) 776-3030

Domino's Nisky Center is on the same premises as Nisky Center Shopping Center, and is a good choice for people thinking about exploring this part of St. Thomas. It is 1.6 miles west of Charlotte Amalie. Hoping to indulge a bit on pizza during your stay? If so, consider making this fun restaurant a permanent plan in your vacation agenda.

Italian Restaurants
Name Location Type Phone Number
Café Amici Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 779-9000
Domino's Nisky Center 1.3 mi. West of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 776-3030
Domino's Tutu Park Mall 0.5 mi. West of Central Anna's Retreat Italian (340) 775-3400
Pesce 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town Italian (340) 714-7874
Pie Whole 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 642-5074
Pizza Hut Wheatley Center 1.2 mi. East of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 774-7975
Portobello Ristorante Central St. Thomas Italian (340) 777-8800
Senor Pizza 1.7 mi. East of Central Maroon Town Italian (340) 775-3030
Virgilio's Restaurant Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 776-4920

Similar Food

Room with a View

If you're willing to step just outside the box, there are similar flavors to be experienced at establishments like the following:

Restaurants with Similar Cuisine
Restaurant Name Phone Cuisine Location
Schnitzel Haus (340) 776-7198 German 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Sangria's Beachside Bistro (340) 714-7874 Mediterranean 0.8 mi. Southeast of Central Red Hook
Epernay (340) 774-5348 French 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Room with a View (340) 774-2377 Greek 0.5 mi. East of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Alexander's Bella Blu (340) 774-4349 European 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Tavern On The Waterfront (340) 776-4328 European Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Amalia Cafe (340) 714-7373 Spanish Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Grande Cru (340) 774-7263 Mediterranean 0.8 mi. East-Southeast of Downtown Charlotte Amalie

Or you can sink your teeth into the signature items offered at restaurants like these:

Restaurants with Similar Specialties
Restaurant Name Phone Specialty Location
Slice VI - Craft Pizza & Cafe (340) 777-5423 Pizza 1.9 mi. East-Northeast of Central Maroon Town
Presto Marketplace (340) 715-6125 Pizza 1.7 mi. Southeast of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Rum Shandy (340) 775-7861 Pizza 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
North Side Bistro & Brewery (340) 775-5098 Pasta 2.2 mi. Northwest of Central Charlotte Amalie
Dinghy's Beach Bar & Grill (340) 227-5525 Pizza 2.5 mi. South West of Central Charlotte Amalie
Thirteen (340) 774-6800 Pizza Central St. Thomas
Coconuts Bar & Grill (340) 774-0099 Pizza Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Island Time Pub (340) 774-2929 Pizza 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town
Caribbean Steakhouse & Saloon (340) 775-7060 Pasta 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town
Mimi's Seaside Bistro (340) 775-2081 Pasta 2.8 mi. Southeast of Central Charlotte Amalie

Despite your dining plans, you may find the best foods in the Virgin Islands are the ones that you casually come across while trekking the town of your choice. But, including a few delicious-sounding restaurants on your schedule, will keep this aspect of your trip worry free. To find out even more about the culinary options awaiting you, check out this page.


Help us improve! We welcome your corrections and suggestions.

About Food