Italian Cuisine on St. Thomas

While exploring the Virgin Islands, expect to come upon a wide range of places to eat. Can't resist Italian food during your holiday here? Guests should check out the restaurants known for this style of cooking. Luckily, you're likely to come across quite a broad selection of restaurants within this culinary category.

With lots to tempt your palate, from the very casual locale of Pizza Hut Wheatley Center to the much anticipated dinner service at Pie Whole, you could encounter a dish worth sharing - or not, as the case may be.

Restaurants Map

Take time to pursue the large collection of restaurants specializing in Italian food available. Find the one that makes your mouth water and click its name to find out more about its specialties, style, and what you can do nearby.


Red Hook, St. Thomas | (340) 714-7874

Pesce, which is on the premises of American Yacht Harbor, is situated near the heart of Red Hook. Sure to please everyone, Pesce isn't just Italian cuisine and pasta, but it's also masters of pizza. <p>The dining room at Pesce is reminiscent of an old world Italian bistro with comfortable high-back leather seating and purposely distressed walls.</p>

Virgilio's Restaurant

Downtown Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas | (340) 776-4920

Virgilio's Restaurant is found within downtown Charlotte Amalie, just outside the heart of Charlotte Amalie. When it comes to specialty Italian food, this possible dining pick is known for its pasta and pizza. <p>While you sit in Virgilio's, you will be led through a meal of homemade pastas and soups, prepared with "Grandma's" old recipes. Your elegant meal will be complimented with the soft music in the background and professional service.</p>

Café Amici

Downtown Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas | (340) 779-9000

Positioned near the middle of downtown Charlotte Amalie, Café Amici is located at A.H. Riise. Though they're broadly known for Italian cuisine, the kitchen at Café Amici is especially proud of their pasta and pizza. <p>Café Amici is an open air spot with a bistro-style ambiance.</p>

Pie Whole

Frenchtown, St. Thomas | (340) 642-5074

Pie Whole is a good choice for you to consider if you're thinking about visiting this neighborhood or the surrounding area. If you're wondering, Charlotte Amalie is to the east. Travelers who are in the mood for pizza will thoroughly love stopping here during a trip to Frenchtown. <p>Make no mistake, it is the pizza that is the main player here. With authentic brick oven pizza and fresh local ingredients, the pizzas are a delicious addition on St. Thomas. Besides their pizza, they also serve several entrees including basic spaghetti with meat, and fettuccine.</p>

Domino's Tutu Park Mall

Anna's Retreat, St. Thomas | (340) 775-3400

Domino's Tutu Park Mall is located in Anna's Retreat, a town on St. Thomas; two and a half miles (four kilometers) to the east of Charlotte Amalie. Head on over to Anna's Retreat if you're a fan of Italian cuisine, but particularly pizza. <p>Whatever you're craving, you can add it to your pizza at Domino's. If you'd like to skew from the norm, order a hot Italian sub, some wings, or a build-it-yourself pasta dish.</p>

Italian Restaurants
Name Location Type Phone Number
Café Amici Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 779-9000
Da Pizza Boat 2.5 mi. South West of Central Charlotte Amalie Italian --
Domino's Nisky Center 1.3 mi. West of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 776-3030
Domino's Tutu Park Mall 0.5 mi. West of Central Anna's Retreat Italian (340) 775-3400
Dorothy's Pizzeria Restaurant & Bar Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 714-1313
Pesce 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town Italian (340) 714-7874
Pie Whole 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 642-5074
Pizza Hut Veteran's Drive 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 774-2291
Pizza Hut Wheatley Center 1.2 mi. East of Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 774-7975
Pizzeria Amore Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 774-2822
Portobello Ristorante Central St. Thomas Italian (340) 777-8800
Senor Pizza 1.7 mi. East of Central Maroon Town Italian (340) 775-3030
Virgilio's Restaurant Downtown Charlotte Amalie Italian (340) 776-4920

Similar Food

Tavern On The Waterfront

Also worth considering if you really love Italian food, maybe you should explore related flavor profiles at local places like these:

Restaurants with Similar Cuisine
Restaurant Name Phone Cuisine Location
Sangria's Beachside Bistro (340) 714-7874 Mediterranean 0.8 mi. Southeast of Central Red Hook
Room with a View (340) 774-2377 Greek 0.5 mi. East of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Amalia Cafe (340) 714-7373 Spanish Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Schnitzel Haus (340) 776-7198 German 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Alexander's Bella Blu (340) 774-4349 Mediterranean 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Epernay (340) 774-5348 French 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Grande Cru (340) 774-7263 Mediterranean 0.8 mi. East-Southeast of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Tavern On The Waterfront (340) 776-4328 European Downtown Charlotte Amalie

Plus, we recommend you take a look at the featured specials prepared at some of these restaurants:

Restaurants with Similar Specialties
Restaurant Name Phone Specialty Location
Thirteen (340) 774-6800 Pizza Central St. Thomas
North Side Bistro & Brewery (340) 775-5098 Pasta 2.2 mi. Northwest of Central Charlotte Amalie
Dinghy's Beach Bar & Grill (340) 227-5525 Pizza 2.5 mi. South West of Central Charlotte Amalie
Island Time Pub (340) 774-2929 Pizza 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town
Coconuts Bar & Grill (340) 774-0099 Pizza Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Magens Bay Cafe & Pizzeria -- Pizza 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Rum Shandy (340) 775-7861 Pizza 0.6 mi. West-Southwest of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Caribbean Steakhouse & Saloon (340) 775-7060 Pasta 1.6 mi. East of Central Maroon Town
Presto Marketplace (340) 715-6125 Pizza 1.7 mi. Southeast of Downtown Charlotte Amalie
Mimi's Seaside Bistro (340) 775-2081 Pasta 2.8 mi. Southeast of Central Charlotte Amalie

Guests often find that the best cuisines in the Virgin Islands are those that you stumble upon while journeying to and from your hotel. But of course, it's still a good idea to plan on visiting specific venues. To learn more about the dining options waiting for you, check out this page.


Help us improve! We welcome your corrections and suggestions.

About Food